I’ve never been a baseball cap kind of guy.
I’ve bought a bunch, but never got used to wearing them.
I do have this navy Polo Sport “dad hat”, the only cap I’ve worn relatively consistently since I bought it 20ish years ago. But in general, hats like this never fit my aesthetic.
I like the idea of hats, but I wanted something more elevated. As I got older and more willing to experiment, I started wearing fedoras.
I’ve tried on and purchased a number of fedoras the past few years. And while I’m no hat expert, I’ve learned a bit about them.
So in this article, I’ll do my best to show you everything I’ve learned about how to wear a fedora – and that will be important to you, should you want to start wearing fedoras too.
But before we discuss fedoras, here’s a hat style to avoid
Admittedly, the first ones I bought were terrible: cheaply-made straw-like versions with tacky bands and short, stingy brims. I was still learning and didn’t know any better.
Which leads me to my first point.
The stingy brim, the sharp, pinched crown, the permanently up-turned brim at the back paired with the a down-angled brim at the front, usually made from a cheap, stiff straw…
This, my friend, is a trilby. It’s not a fedora.
Cheap versions of the trilby you find in run-of-the-mill stores are not worth your time or money.
On top of that, because of their ill proportions, trilbies look good on absolutely no one. If you’re going to venture into brimmed hat territory, go with a classic fedora; avoid trilbies at all costs.
Anatomy of a fedora
I should note that while there are plenty of brimmed hat styles (from Homburgs and Bowlers to Westerns and Porkpies), in this article I’m talking specifically about one type: the classic fedora.
The kind you see in old 50’s movies or in mafia classics like The Godfather.
In general, a fedora is described as a soft felt hat with a lengthwise crease in the crown, two slight front (or side) pinch creases, a medium/wide brim, and a decorative band at the base of the crown where it meets the brim.
There are three main elements of the fedora: The crown, the brim, and the band.
Crown height, brim width, and band width all vary from hat to hat, so I’ll break down the specifics of each below.
Quick note: Wearing a fedora feels weird at first
If you want to know how to wear a fedora for yourself but you’ve never worn a brimmed hat before, it’s gonna feel weird. You’ll think the brim is too wide, the crown is too tall, the pinch looks weird, etc.
As with anything new, it takes a bit of getting used to. You have to actually wear hats to get used to them. It takes a few wears. And believe me, your tastes will change as you acclimate to the style and start to try others.
Another thing: you may feel inclined to approach this whole brimmed hat topic analytically and ask questions like:
- “What’s the best crown height for my face shape?”
- ”What’s the ideal crown-to-brim ratio?”
- ”I’m 6’ tall, have broad shoulders, and a defined jaw. Should I wear a 3” brim or a 3.25” brim?”
First, relax. Take a breath.
Second, find comfort in the fact that there is no right or wrong. It’s all personal preference. Some hats may look better on you than others. That’s for you to decide. It becomes much easier once you try a bunch of hats on.
Speaking of: when it comes to how things fit, my best advice is to go and try a bunch of stuff on (yep, just repeated myself, on purpose).
No matter if it’s jeans, dress shirts, or hats… you have to try plenty of different models and styles to find one that works for you.
You can read all the suggestions in the world but you won’t know how good something looks until you try on 5 other things that look shitty on you. You can’t develop a personal preference until then, either.
So that’s my advice. Go out and try on some hats before getting all analytical about exact measurements and ratios.
Even within the family of fedoras, you can have slightly different shaped crowns. Here’s a good forum thread that shows a number of styles.
I’m partial to a shorter crown with a center dent and a gently pinched front. After trying many different crease styles and crown heights, this combo looks the best on me.
The only way you’ll know what looks good on you, as mentioned above, is to try a few. Throw on fedoras with tall crowns, shorter crowns, deep pinches on the front, pinches on the side, etc…
Men who prefer a more custom experience can purchase a hat with an open crown (fully rounded, no creases or dents) and shape one themselves.
Keep in mind that an open crown is naturally taller to allow for bashing and shaping. Once you’ve done so, the overall height will be shorter. As a rule of thumb, 5.5” would be the minimum height (give or take, depending on your head) needed to do any shaping without the top of your head popping out the dent.
I haven’t done this myself just yet. But as I acquire more fedoras, I’ve become more interested in creating my own shapes (and being able to experiment with ones I wouldn’t normally buy in pre-shaped hats).
Go with a more substantial brim. I’d say around 2.5” is your sweet spot.
There’s a bit of leeway here; if you’re a thin guy with a narrow face, a shorter brim (say, 2”) may look good on you without dipping down into terrible trilby territory.
If you’re a bigger guy or you have a wider face, a slightly wider brim (3-3.5”) may suit you better.
It’s all about proportion in relation to your head, face, and shoulders… similar to lapel, tie, and collar widths. But again, you have to try on a few models to see what you like best.
Fedoras are usually made from wool felt, as well as more exotic rabbit, cashmere, and even beaver felt. Warm weather versions are made from straw.
Straw fedoras can look similar to Panama hats, but Panama hats are specifically handwoven in Ecuador, usually from the toquilla palm.
Fedoras typically come with a grosgrain band of varying height (usually around 1-1.5”).
Adding any accoutrement—feathers, a cool enamel pin, button, monogram, etc.—is totally up to you. This is where the “personal” in personal style comes in. I keep a few feathers and sometimes I’ll wear them in my hat, other times I won’t.
“Can you pack a fedora?”
You can, if you buy one that was designed to be packable.
I have a straw fedora from Goorin Bros. and two wool felt fedoras from Bailey that are packable. This comes in handy when you want to travel with your hat. You simply roll it up and keep in your jacket pocket or carry-on if you don’t want to wear it on the flight.
Articles of Style did a quick and easy hat folding tutorial that you can find here.
Where to buy your fedora
There are plenty of reputable brands to buy your first (or next) fedora. Expect to pay at least $100 for a basic fedora and $250+ for a really nice one.
While I have a decent, growing collection of fedoras at this point, none of mine are on the high end of the spectrum. I believe my most expensive one retails at $150, and I’ve picked up a few on sale.
Here are a few brands to browse:
If possible, I suggest heading to a store and trying on at least 5 different fedoras.
As always, it’s worth it to spend a bit more on quality. But I understand the desire to not spend too much if you’re still testing out something new in your wardrobe.
Goorin Bros.’ Dean The Butcher is one model I’ve noticed looks great on many guys. I own one of these and it’s definitely a favorite.
The Curtis from Bailey is another great model to start with.
Thanks for reading! If you’re on Instagram, follow me there for occasional photos of me wearing a fedora.
Learn a few shortcuts to dressing well
Enter your first name and email, and I'll send you a free eGuide with quick and easy tips you can use today.