All In The Details: Black leather shoes CAN be interesting! (Leather Shoes, part II)

August 23, 2012 · 21 comments

in All In The Details

(This is Part II of Leather Shoes in our ongoing series, All In The Details. Check out Part I here.)

Hey gents,

Here’s a twist on the old standby.

If you’ve been reading EG for any length of time, you’ve probably caught wind of my disdain for black leather shoes as the all-in-one solution for every dressy occasion. I think brown leather is much more versatile and interesting, and most men should avoid black unless they’re funeral directors, undertakers, or comic book super villains.

Aaanyway, black has its place in every man’s wardrobe but I think it should be used sparingly.

I can see why guys gravitate towards black shoes though. It’s difficult to go wrong; at the same time, it’s pretty damn boring if you ask me… especially if you have other choices.

One thing I do really love is MIXING black with brown tones.

I can hear it already

The throngs of dudes all going “Say whaaa” because they grew up hearing you shouldn’t wear black and brown together.

Well, good thing you’re an EG reader, because when done correctly, black and brown can be ultra awesome together.

When it comes to shoes, here’s just one example: black leather shoes with a natural-colored sole.

Combining the old basic black leather dress shoe and sexing it up a bit with the contrasting sole is the simplest, classiest way to mix the two colors in your shoe.

And doesn’t that just look infinitely more interesting?

By the way, I took this photo at a Nordstrom Rack somewhere in Indiana while I was out there visiting the future in-laws, and in my haste, I forgot to take note of the actual shoe brand and model.

I was trying to snap it quickly because I didn’t want a sales associate to see me, but lo and behold, one walks right up to me as I took it and asks if I need help finding anything. Ha! Didn’t see her coming. Awkward.

But at least I was able to get this visual example for you!

I do believe it’s an Allen Edmonds model, though I can’t say for certain. Try a little Googling and let me know if you can find this shoe on the interwebz, and I’ll share it here on the site.

(Editor’s note: Thanks to BJ for the link in the comments, and Kevin for confirming. It’s the Allen Edmonds Players shoe, available here.)

Here’s another that I’ve been eyeing for a while, in a loafer style from LL Bean Signature.

“So do you still hate black leather shoes?”

I wouldn’t say hate… that’s a strong word. I still don’t like them as the standard solution for all outfits because that’s way boring.

BUT! If you want to wear them, have to wear them, or are in the market for a pair, look for a black leather shoe with a contrasting natural sole to give your kicks a nice little… kick.

In other news

You may notice articles have been a little slow lately. Sorry about that! I’m working on a new project for EG (think Graduating Your Style but even more in-depth, interactive, visual, and interesting), and doing other little upgrades to the site. It will pick back up again soon, promise.

I’m still interacting plenty on Twitter, Facebook, and Tumblr, so come by and say hi!

About

Barron is the founder and editor of Effortless Gent, a site dedicated to helping dudes figure out what looks best on them. He also co-founded Fifth&Brannan, a menswear label based in San Francisco. Connect with him on Twitter and Facebook.

  • http://twitter.com/bjmcgeever BJ McGeever
  • kevin

    it’s the edmond’s player….the only black pair of dress shoes i own!

  • ChrisReetz

    Great take on mixing black with brown; nice and subtle while still having an impact. And who doesn’t like a shoe with Player’s in the name! They will be my first choice when I’m back in the market for some black shoes.

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    You guys are good. Thanks!

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Not a bad one to own! Thanks for confirming, shout out in the updated post above.

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Rad, thanks BJ. Added it to the post above.

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Same here. I haven’t had the urge to buy a pair (I don’t even own a pair) of black leather shoes for quite a while, but once the need arises, I’m picking something like this.

  • kevin

    You have taught us well!

  • http://twitter.com/ambassadorbruny M. Ambassador Bruny

    Great piece Barron. I really like that shoe. I liked the Allen Edmonds Strand in brown so much that I got one in black as well.

    Did you hear about the fall trend of having different color shoe laces with your dress shoes? I thought, “that would be so cheesy,” until I saw it for myself. My wife works at Neiman’s and showed me an article. If I find the link, I will share it.

    Peace

  • Chris Taylor

    I actually am a Funeral Director ( well, a future one. I’m in school for it, and work part time at a funeral home.) and am constantly on the lookout for ways to update the “old man” style prevalent in the industry. Keep up the good work!

  • http://twitter.com/ambassadorbruny M. Ambassador Bruny
  • Anonymous

    It looks like shoe polish or dye or something has leaked onto the sole – is it supposed to look like that or is it a damaged shoe?

  • Chris G.

    Would you still choose brown over black for events in the evening/night?

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    I think it’s just the fluorescent lighting in the store + the instagram filter. If you look at the link from BJ (above) you’ll see a more accurately-lit product shot.

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    No way! Do Funeral Directors actually have to wear black? I just sorta use that as an example but have never checked into the dress code in detail.

    In any case, glad to hear you’re looking for ways to refresh the industry’s stodgy style. Why not, right?

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Hey Mike, yeah I think that has been trending for the past couple seasons. It’s probably reaching a peak right now, if not already on its way down. Trendiness aside, I always promote the pop of color, whether it be laces, socks, or bow ties :)

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Are you going to a formal evening event? If it’s black tie, white tie, or some other formal event, then definitely black.

    If it’s creative black tie or something similar, the rules are bit more lax, in which case I’d do a deep, dark, midnight blue tux with burgundy plain-toed lace-ups, or a brown tux with brown lace-ups of course. This is assuming I had the pieces at my disposal. Google those two types of tuxes, they look pretty snazzy.

  • Chris Taylor

    As a whole, required dress code is very conservative, and black shoes/charcoal suit is pretty much the norm. I tend to go with colored shirts and ties to liven up (seriously, no pun intended) the work wardrobe.

  • http://twitter.com/ambassadorbruny M. Ambassador Bruny

    Amen for pop of color and for bow ties. Just starting to up my sock game ;)

  • Lee William

    Hi guys, does anyone if there are any shops anymore that make custom or made to order shoes? I know a family of cordwainers and was wondering if there still is a market for made to order men’s shoes like in the olden days. thanks.

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    There’s always a market for made-to-order :)

Previous post:

Next post: